Mama Knows Breast




Andi in the news

Watch Andi on the CBS Early Show: Click here.

Watch Andi on The NBC NIGHTLY NEWS: Click here.

Watch Andi on THE TODAY SHOW: Click here.



The Dangers of Crib Bumpers

Bookmark and Share

When our first son was born I remember debating whether or not to put bumpers on his crib.  I liked the way they matched the sheets.  And the displays in the store always looked so nice.  But then I started to read stuff about the suffocation dangers of bumpers.  I found mixed information, and our pediatrician didn’t have a strong opinion.  So I got suckered into buying the bumpers.  I stopped using them, however,  as soon as I realized they obstructed my view of the baby.

Since then, the data has become much more clear.  And now The Consumer Product Safety Commission is taking a closer look at bumpers and other sleep products.  From the NYT:

Three years ago, Dr. Bradley Thach, a professor of pediatrics at Washington University in St. Louis, published findings that had the potential to upend nurseries across the nation, and perhaps save some lives too.

Dr. Bradley Thach’s findings about the dangers of crib bumpers are now getting a second look by the Consumer Products Safety Commission.

In reviewing data from the Consumer Products Safety Commission, Dr. Thach concluded that crib bumpers — the padding wrapped around the inside of a crib that often matches the bedding—were killing babies. In a 10-year period beginning in 1995, he found 27 suffocation deaths involving bumper pads, and he theorized that many more might have occurred because of inconsistencies in the data.

“Because bumpers can cause death, we conclude that they should not be used,” he warned.

The Consumer Products Safety Commission initially ignored the findings. Last summer, it reached the same conclusion as a trade group representing product manufacturers, which asserted that other factors, like a crib crowded with pillows or babies sleeping on their stomachs, might have been a factor in those deaths, rather than the bumpers. As a result, most parents remained unaware of the debate over the safety of crib bumpers.

Now, prompted by consumer advocates and news reports highlighting potential dangers, the commission has reversed itself and decided to take a deeper look at crib bumpers as part of a broader regulatory crackdown on the hazards of an extensive line of baby sleep products that have been blamed for more injuries and deaths…



2 Responses to “The Dangers of Crib Bumpers”

When I was shopping for crib sheets three years ago for G, I noticed that the bumper sets had a warning that stated that using bumpers may cause suffocation. We didn’t use bumpers (and never planned too), but many of my friends opted for breathable, mesh bumpers. I wonder if there has been research on those.

We didn’t use bumpers because it seemed an unnecessary expense and because we were frightened into it by parenting sites that cited this kind of research. However, I have to ask; why are we not recommending against riding in cars, and playing with toys, and a multitude of other things that we do every day that are far more dangerous than using crib bumpers. Those 27 deaths are terrible, but they are only a minute fraction of the population. Many more children are killed by other things that we have no intention of eliminating.
I don’t know. Sometimes it seems like people are trying to make parents fearful of almost everything, instead of focusing on the things of which they should really be cautious.

Leave a comment